Asheville City Schools makes 'monumental’ decision on CBD use – Asheville Citizen-Times

ASHEVILLE – Asheville City Schools officially became a WNC outlier when it approved at a May 4 board meeting a revised drug policy that allows the use of CBD, the chemical compound found in cannabis.

ACS broke from several neighboring districts – Buncombe, Transylvania, and Henderson – which forbade CBD this winter. ACS’s reasoning for the decision was simple.

“Many families are using CBD oil as medicinal supplements for their health and wellness effects,” Shane Cassada, ACS assistant superintendent, said in an email to the Citizen Times. “Effectively leaving CBD on the (prohibited) list would have created a much larger issue that is not currently a problem.”

Cassida said the district’s decision was based on advice from its legal counsel. Among the other 14 western-most districts in North Carolina, 10 list CBD as a prohibited substance.

Even this past year, as dozens of North Carolina school districts moved to ban cannabidiol, better known as CBD, ACS stood pat, allowing students and staff to keep using the popular chemical compound. In May, ACS board members – voting unanimously – made it official and deleted CBD from a proposed list of prohibited substances. The district’s drug policies, for students and staff, apply at school, on school property, and during school-sponsored events. 

At issue is competing district views on how to approach the increasingly common hemp extract whose impacts on bodies and minds, both young and old, are still being understood.  

„I think if people haven’t used it and seen the positive side effects they may not understand why some parents are pushing for it,” said Kara Kihm, an ACS parent who gives her elementary-age daughter CBD oil at night to help calm her for sleep.

„I think it’s great they are allowing it. It seems to have a very positive impact on some kids.”

More: To control its financial destiny, Eliada turns to growing hemp, making CBD

West Asheville CBD vendor ransacked by reported hemp thieves

ACS breaks from neighbors on CBD

In late September 2019, the North Carolina School Board Association revised its drugs and alcohol policies, for student and staff, and inserted “cannabidiol (CBD)” on its prohibited substance list.

This past school year, 47 school districts out of the state’s 115 districts adopted the NCSBA’s policies of banning “any substance containing cannabidiol (CBD) or tetrahydrocannabinol (THC).” An inability for schools to distinguish CBD from THC, a board association representative told the Citizen Times, drove its recommendations to outlaw both.

“School officials have a hard enough time managing discipline when students are vaping and using substances, said Janine Murphy, assistant legal counsel for the NCSBA. “For us the default was to ban the substances altogether rather than ask school officials to try to figure out whether whatever the student claimed was legal or not.”

In December, school boards in Henderson County Public Schools and Transylvania County Schools voted to disallow CBD. Buncombe County Schools voted to prohibit CBD for students and staff in January.

Students caught breaking district drug policies can face a range of consequences, from parental involvement for minor violations to out-of-school suspensions for major violations. Staff who disobey these policies will face disciplinary action from their school boards that could result in losing their jobs.

During a February board work session, ACS actually considered adopting the state board’s CBD ban on staff. But when the NCSBA-recommended drug policy came up, board member Joyce Brown questioned why a legal substance like CBD should be outlawed.

“I think in Asheville a lot of people are using alternative medicine, like CBD, and it just doesn’t make sense for us to add something to that policy that is not an illicit drug,” Brown told the Citizen Times. “It doesn’t seem like it’s out of the question that somebody might be using it for pain management or some other health condition.”

No one at the work session meeting voiced disagreement with Brown’s argument and the board removed “CBD” from its policy revision. Then in May, the board removed “CBD” from its list of prohibited substances for students (existing district policies on tobacco and vaping instruments will prevent students from smoking or vaping CBD on school grounds or events).

Policymakers’ quandary

Cannabis experts across the country say policymakers continue wrestling with CBD questions, both inside and outside school walls.

“In many ways, the dilemma that schools are in is a mini version of what society is figuring out more broadly in the workplace and just at the federal, state and local levels,” said Paul Seaborn, professor of commerce at the University of Virginia, who researches cannabis business and policy.

“It’s moving in fits and starts at all those levels right now. It seems like it’s finally getting to a point where schools are at least seeing it as a choice.”

With the ground beneath the nascent CBD industry still unsettled, some see schools and parents as forces to tilt public perception in CBD’s favor. In ACS’s decision, some see a budding trend.

“This is going to be monumental,” said Franny Tacy, of Leicester, who owns the CBD company Franny’s Farmacy. “What they need is one district to do it and set the example.”

More: Y’all ride freight?: The splendor, squalor and past-lives of Asheville train-hoppers

Is cannabis the new casino? Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians looks to invest

Praise outpacing research

CBD is derived from hemp, a plant in the cannabis family. What distinguishes hemp from marijuana, another cannabis, is tetrahydrocannabinol, or THC, a psychoactive compound that alters the brain and can change perception, mood and behaviors.

The THC level of hemp is .3% or less, while marijuana has THC levels at least 20 to 50 times greater. 

In the 2018 Farm Bill, the federal government legalized hemp, and CBD’s popularity has exploded since, including among parents who say CBD mitigated problems their children have with anxiety, mood, and sleep. Yet precisely what benefits people reap from CBD remains a matter of developing research.

In 2018, the FDA approved its first (and still only) CBD-based drug, Epidiolex, to treat rare forms of childhood epilepsy. Researchers say there’s little definitive proof backing up CBD’s benefits beyond treating certain seizures.

“There are also reports that it relieves withdrawal in heroin users,” wrote Harriet de Wit, a professor of psychiatry and behavioral neuroscience at the University of Chicago, in an email to the Citizen Times. “Other than that, there is surprisingly little support for the many claims that are made about the drug.”

Still, de Wit said the compound is generally considered safe for all ages, and no states have placed age restrictions on CBD’s use or purchase.

More: 'Completely uncharted territory’: Special education challenges in the shadow of COVID-19

Brian Gordon is the education and social issues reporter for the Citizen Times. He’s won awards for stories on schools and guinea pigs. Reach him at bgordon@citizentimes.com or on Twitter @briansamuel92.

Keep local journalism possible with a subscription to the Citizen Times.